Welcome to Mario's Pizzeria of Seaford
Mario's Pizzeria of Seaford, located at 3842 Sunrise Hwy, Seaford, NY, stands out as a beloved local gem known for its fantastic buffalo chicken pizza and delectable pasta. With a warm atmosphere and an inviting staff, patrons rave about the attentive service, especially from staff member Brian. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a leisurely meal, the food consistently impresses with fresh ingredients and generous portions. From catered events to casual lunches, Mario’s is not just a pizzeria—it’s a tradition that resonates with the community, making each visit a delightful experience worth savoring.
Mario's Pizzeria of Seaford: Reviews & Ratings
I went for the best buffalo chicken pizza in the whole Long Island !! And best pasta ever!! Mario’s pizza is a family tradition best of the best!!
Make sure that i have lunch here at least once a week, a lot of weeks it's 2 times a week. I usually deal with Brian and he is always extremely friendly and very attentive. Highly recommend making this your new Pizza/Italian restaurant, there is nothing here that they don't do well.
Worked with Mike to cater a birthday party. He was very patient, great recommendations, and very reasonably priced for the amount of food we ordered. Food was fresh and delicious. A lot of left overs but that's a good problem.
Great Food, Great People , local area perfect for grabbing a slices or just slow down and relax
1st time, buffalo chicken & regular slices... so delish... beautiful chucks of chicken on the Buffalo slice... nice crust and today was buy any slice and get free plain slice ... can’t beat that ... great service and staff...
Grandma's pizza was to die for, as always. You can't complete a family meal without ordering the fried dough for dessert. Customer service was top notch. The drinks were cold and there wasn't much of a wait for fresh pizza. Would definitly recommend and can't wait to go back!
The best pizzeria in South Nassau! They took very good care of us during the pandemic and were always cheerful. You can't go wrong with anything you order. The whole wheat pizza is fabulous! For my birthday they sent me a coupon for a free personalized pan pizza. It was incredible and enough for 4. The slices were heavy because they are loaded with cheese. It blows away my memories of Pizzaria Uno. The calzones are old school Brooklyn. They are also very filling and made with good quality ingredients. The manager even called me to see how I liked the pizza. Once again, the best pizza on Long Island! Thank you, Mario's !
Only pizza my daughter likes . She says this is real pizza. Amazing service as always specially Mike.
Location
-
3842 Sunrise Hwy, Seaford, NY 11783, United States Hotline: +1 516-826-5200
Welcome to Mario's Pizzeria of Seaford, a neighborhood gem nestled at 3842 Sunrise Hwy in Seaford, NY. Known for its warm atmosphere and friendly service, this pizzeria has earned its stripes as a beloved destination for both locals and visitors alike. The notable phone number, +1 516-826-5200, is your gateway to some of the finest pizza and Italian cuisine in the area.
Mario's Pizzeria takes pride in crafting dishes that resonate with family traditions. Customers rave about the mouthwatering buffalo chicken pizza, touted as the best on Long Island by none other than RAY URENA. This iconic dish features tender chunks of chicken atop a perfectly baked crust, infused with just the right level of spice and flavor. It's no surprise that visitors leave with satisfied palates and nostalgic memories.
But Mario's is not just about pizza. Diners like HARRISON LOWE share an affinity for their pasta offerings, which have garnered equal acclaim for their quality and taste. Weekly stops at the pizzeria have become a ritual, thanks to the attentive staff led by friendly faces like Brian. Customers appreciate the consistency and excellence in service that sets Mario's apart from other dining establishments.
For those looking to celebrate special occasions, catering is a breeze. DAVID GELLER can attest to this, as he described his experience working with Mike to cater a birthday party. The fresh and delicious food received glowing reviews, leaving guests with a memorable feast and a "good problem" of leftovers. It’s a clear sign that Mario's delivers not just satisfaction, but abundance.
The local vibe is palpable at Mario's Pizzeria, where PEEWEE captures the essence of the community: great food and great people. Whether you're stopping by for a quick slice on the go or settling in for a leisurely meal, the atmosphere encourages you to slow down and savor every bite. The service team, including the ever-charming staff highlighted by DIMITRI LASKAS, ensures that each visit is comfortable and enjoyable.
In closing, Mario's Pizzeria of Seaford stands out not only for its exceptional dishes but also for its unwavering commitment to service and community. If you haven't already, make this your go-to destination for pizza and Italian cuisine—your taste buds will thank you!